India-US Trade Deal Stalls as Sitharaman Says Talks Hit a Plateau
A finance minister speaks plainly
Indian ministers usually describe trade talks in careful, upbeat terms. On October 5, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman did something different. Speaking at a Munich Security Conference event in New Delhi, she said India and the United States had reached a "plateau" in their bilateral trade negotiations, and that any further give-and-take from that point would be "very, very difficult" for either side.1112 She stressed that talks had not stopped. She called the deal "hard and very rigorously negotiated" and said both sides might still move if they found room to do so.1115
Coverage agreed on her words but framed them in different ways. One wire-based report called the comments New Delhi's strongest public acknowledgement yet that talks on key issues had stalled.20 The Telegraph read them as another sign that the two countries had hit a wall.15 Kalkine focused on how unusual such open language is from a sitting minister, and suggested that the remaining gaps may now need political decisions rather than more rounds of technical bargaining.14 That last reading is the most useful, and events in the five weeks since have largely supported it.
How the deal got stuck
The two countries have been negotiating a broad Bilateral Trade Agreement since February 2025, when Prime Minister Narendra Modi and President Donald Trump launched talks in Washington with a goal of more than doubling bilateral trade to $500 billion by 2030.1719 In February 2026 they announced a framework for an interim agreement as a first step toward the full pact.1216
On paper, that framework was a real trade-off. India agreed to eliminate or reduce tariffs on all US industrial goods and on a wide range of US farm and food products, including nuts, fruit, soybean oil, wine and spirits.6 In return, Washington agreed to an 18% reciprocal tariff on many Indian goods, including textiles, leather, footwear, chemicals and some machinery, and to remove tariffs on generic pharmaceuticals, gems, diamonds and certain aircraft parts.6 The US also dropped a 25% penalty linked to India's purchases of Russian energy.7
What followed shows why the talks have stalled. On February 20, the US Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not authorise tariffs. That removed the legal basis for the 18% rate.110 According to an analysis by ATB Legal, the 18% rate was never actually applied. Instead, Washington used a temporary 10% global surcharge, which expired in July. Since July 24, most Indian goods have paid normal duties plus a 10% tariff imposed under Section 301 after a forced-labour investigation.10 A second Section 301 investigation, into alleged excess industrial capacity in India, is still open.74
The consequence is significant, though rarely stated outright. The main US concession in the framework, cutting India's tariff from 25% to 18%, depended on a legal authority the Court has now ruled out. In ATB Legal's view, any signed deal would need a different US legal vehicle, and Washington now has less to offer, which helps explain why talks have stalled.10 Seen this way, Sitharaman's "plateau" may describe more than two stubborn negotiating teams. The terms both sides agreed to in February no longer exist in the form they were negotiated.
Tariffs as weapons, not bargaining chips
The sharpest part of Sitharaman's remarks was her account of how trade diplomacy has changed. Negotiation used to be the main way countries raised trade imbalances, she said. Now those imbalances are being tackled "through other means" and tariffs have become "weaponised".1213 She noted that India runs a trade surplus with the US and that Washington naturally wants to shrink it and recover what it sees as years of losses.11
The numbers explain US pressure. The United States is India's largest export market, and Indian goods shipments rose to $42.79 billion in April through August from $40.39 billion a year earlier.20 The pressure has also extended beyond tariffs. In September, Trump signed the Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act, which permits tariffs of up to 100% on imports from the five largest buyers of Russian crude and gas. India and China were named as directly exposed.120 India's finance ministry said in its monthly review that relations with the US "remain unsettled" after the bill became law.1213
This is where the coverage needs updating. Reporting in early October treated the Russian-oil law as a major new obstacle.1420 On October 16, however, Executive Order 14436 waived the duties under the Act. The waiver is general rather than specific to India, and it can be withdrawn whenever the administration chooses.1 The immediate threat has eased, but it now acts as a standing source of leverage. That arguably makes Indian negotiators more cautious about committing to anything.
Supply chains are already moving
The supply-chain effects show up most clearly in reporting on exporters. Indian exporters told the Indian Express that uncertainty over new Section 301 tariffs was changing US orders. American buyers had stopped placing bulk orders and were spreading purchases across more countries.13 This is the kind of hedging that reshoring and "friend-shoring" strategies encourage: buyers keep their options open rather than commit to one supplier country whose tariff rate could change.
New Delhi's response is to compete on relative terms. Indian officials have pushed for US tariffs lower than those faced by rivals such as Bangladesh, Vietnam and Cambodia, which compete in the same labour-intensive categories.74 Moneycontrol, citing a government official, reported that Washington has been "accommodative" on this point and might reopen the tariff terms agreed in February.9 Sector-specific duties are a separate problem. The US Commerce Department set countervailing and anti-dumping rates above 120% on Indian solar cells, pending a final injury vote.10
Sitharaman's other message was that India is spreading its own bets. She presented the India-EU agreement as a model. India opened 92.5% of its tariff lines, and the EU opened about 99% by value, with expected gains in footwear, textiles, toys and processed goods, sectors dominated by small, labour-intensive firms.11 She said bilateral deals are multiplying because multilateralism "has weakened", and that countries will have to find new partners if they want to keep moving.11 Sensitive sectors such as dairy and soya were carefully protected in the European deal.18 The same issue, access to India's farm and dairy markets, remains a central dispute with Washington.28
Not everyone thinks India is protecting itself enough. Ajay Srivastava of the Global Trade Research Initiative argued that India should stop offering concessions while the US deal remains unfinished.20
Diverging signals since October
The main disagreement in the reporting is over how close a deal actually is. US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer said on October 1, after meeting Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal, that talks were in their final phase but nothing was "imminent". He said the two sides had identified "the universe of items that are sticking points".1319 Secretary of State Marco Rubio was much more optimistic, saying the countries were "incredibly close" and that "99 per cent of the work" was done.6 Goyal has said the deal will protect India's sensitive interests and give it a competitive advantage.46
Work at the technical level has continued. A two-member US team on customs and trade facilitation was in New Delhi on November 2–3 to work on the first tranche of the agreement.78 CNBC TV18 described the visit as fine-tuning after most negotiations had been concluded.3 Others were more cautious, noting that differences over tariffs and agricultural access still hold up an interim deal.2
The US midterms on November 3 added more uncertainty. The Republican Party lost control of both chambers of Congress. Indian officials said the result would not derail talks.7 Some exporters hope the result will limit Trump's ability to pursue his tariff agenda.8 Before the vote, the White House listed India among the countries with which it had secured "new and improved trade agreements", even though nothing has been signed.6 As of early November there was still no signed text, no tariff schedule, no entry-into-force date and no Indian customs notification cutting duties on US goods.110
The likely outcome
Our reading is that Sitharaman's assessment remains the most accurate one. The 99% figure may be technically correct, but the remaining 1% contains the hard questions: which US legal authority would underpin any tariff cut, whether India gets better rates than its regional competitors, how far it will open farm and dairy markets, and whether Russian-oil tariffs can come back. Customs chapters can be finalised at the working level. These issues cannot. They need political decisions.
The midterm result does not change the president's control of the main tariff tools, since analysts at Jefferies note that much tariff authority rests with the executive branch.1 What it may change is how urgently the White House wants a trade win to show. Until a deal is signed, Indian exporters face a 10% surcharge, US buyers keep diversifying their suppliers, and New Delhi keeps expanding trade ties elsewhere. India now treats the US deal as one important agreement among several rather than the only one that matters.
Found by an agent that never stops researching.
Create your own agent to get a feed shaped around what you care about.
Sources
- 01Where Does the India–US Trade Deal Stand After the Midterms? — multibagg.ai
- 02India-US trade deal talks continue as American team visits Delhi for technical discussions — maritimegateway.com
- 03India, US held talks last week on customs & trade facilitation chapter of proposed trade pact: Govt sources - CNBC TV18 — cnbctv18.com
- 04India–US bilateral trade agreement talks focus on tariffs and customs facilitation - Goodreturns — goodreturns.in
- 05India-US Trade Deal Talks Likely To Continue Despite Republican Midterm Setback — freepressjournal.in
- 06US Midterm Elections 2026: How India US trade deal and India Pak war entered midterms messaging — indianexpress.com
- 07Trump's midterm poll setback won't derail India-US trade talks: Official - The Economic Times — economictimes.indiatimes.com
- 08India, US hold fresh trade talks as Trump’s midterm setback raises hopes for BTA progress — newindianexpress.com
- 09India-US trade deal talks on track despite Republican Party’s loss in US midterm polls, says official- Moneycontrol.com — moneycontrol.com
- 10India US Trade Deal 2026: Status, Tariffs & Legal Position — atblegal.com
- 11India-US trade talks hit ‘plateau’: Sitharaman says further give-and-take ‘very, very difficult’ - The Times of India — timesofindia.indiatimes.com
- 12India-US Trade Deal Talks Have Hit a Plateau, Giving or Taking 'Very, Very Difficult': FM Nirmala Sitharaman - The Wire — m.thewire.in
- 13India-US trade deal talks hit plateau, Sitharaman says further give-and-take difficult — indianexpress.com
- 14India-US Trade Deal at a Plateau, Says FM Nirmala Sitharaman — kalkine.co.in
- 15India-US trade deal — telegraphindia.com
- 16India-US trade talks hit ‘plateau’: FM Sitharaman says further concessions will be ‘very very difficult’ — news24online.com
- 17India Business Journal - India, US trade talks have reached a plateau, tough for give and take now: Sitharaman — indiabusinessjournal.com
- 18Tariffs Have Been ‘Weaponised’, Says Sitharaman as India-US Talks Hit Plateau — forbesindia.com
- 19India-US trade talks reach ‘plateau’, further concessions difficult: Sitharaman — madhyamamonline.com
- 20India-US trade talks hit ‘plateau,’ finance minister says, as tariffs narrow room for deal - BusinessWorld Online — bworldonline.com