The governor who wouldn't back down
Since July 1, about 108,000 California state employees have been required to work from a state office four days a week. That rule now sets California apart. Its policy is stricter than those of most comparable states, and stricter than the one in Republican-led Texas. Gov. Gavin Newsom has refused to soften it even as the dispute has spread to pay talks, the Legislature and, in October, the first strike in the history of California's largest state-worker union.
Newsom signed the order, Executive Order N-22-25, in March 2025. It covers roughly 108,000 of the state's more than 245,900 employees. Most of the rest, including prison staff, firefighters, police and custodians, already had to report in person five days a week.13 Bloomberg described the change as doubling the in-office requirement from two days to four and put the number affected at a lower figure of "at least 90,000."15 The order allows one telework day a week. A memo from the governor's office said that a shortage of desks "will not excuse or delay" the return.1211
The rules do include some exemptions. Workers who live 50 miles or more from their office can ask for one, as can people whose jobs take them into the field, such as inspectors and telehealth providers. The state also pays back public transit costs.6 In practice the rollout has been uneven. The Employment Development Department exempted its call centers. The Department of Education stayed on two days a week after a suspected bedbug infestation. The Department of Child Support kept all of its staff on flexible schedules.14
Why California stands out
The comparison with Texas has drawn the most attention. Gov. Greg Abbott banned remote work for Texas state employees in 2025, shortly after President Trump ordered federal workers back to their offices. Abbott reversed course after a review across several agencies found that telework had not hurt productivity and had helped cut turnover.13 Reports differ on the details. CalMatters says the reversal took about three months.1 A later summary says Abbott signed legislation "this summer" to allow telework across state agencies.5 In both versions, Texas tried a strict mandate and then backed off, while California has not.
California also differs from other Democratic-led states with strong public unions. Colorado, Hawaii, Illinois, Massachusetts, New York, Oregon and Washington all still allow some remote work for state employees.13 Only a few states go further than California: Republican-led Nevada and Democratic-led New Mexico require five days in the office. Utah, which has a Republican governor, asks for two.8 Ted Toppin, executive director of the state engineers' union, noted the irony that Newsom wrote a book about modernizing government with technology, yet Texas now has the more flexible telework policy.8
Newsom has given the same reasons throughout. He says in-person work builds community, collaboration and accountability, and he has pointed to small businesses in downtown Sacramento that depend on office workers.5 Sacramento Mayor Kevin McCarty agrees and has said more people downtown brings real economic and social benefits.19
The audit problem
Newsom's critics rely on the state's own audit, and the governor has not directly answered it. The State Auditor estimated that expanded telework could save California up to $225 million a year. Newsom issued his order anyway.13 D'Arcy McLeod, who chairs the bargaining team for the Professional Engineers in California Government, said every Newsom appointee who testified to the auditor described remote work as higher quality and more efficient.6 The Newsom administration's own budget proposal included no new money to help departments make room for the returning workers.45
This is the weakest part of the administration's position. Newsom's case rests on culture and collaboration, which are hard to measure. His opponents have a dollar figure from an independent state office. The governor may be right that something is lost when teams rarely meet in person. But he has not put forward evidence that matches the audit's.
Where the job cuts come in
The office mandate came after several years of cuts to the state workforce. To close a deficit the administration estimated at roughly $47 billion, the 2024 budget planned to eliminate about 10,000 vacant positions and cut state operations by close to 8%. Finance officials told departments not to use layoffs or early retirements to get there.42 That target was later reduced. The 2025-26 budget permanently eliminated 6,002 vacant positions, with expected ongoing savings of about $490 million.48 At a Senate hearing in May 2026, the Legislative Analyst's Office said about 5,000 of those positions had already been removed. Finance officials said around 40,000 state positions sit empty in a typical year.46
The 2025 deficit also shaped the return-to-office fight. To get the four-day rule delayed by a year, unions accepted a personal leave program that lowered the state's pay costs.27 Those deals left out general raises for 2026, even though the state's budget had improved by then.29 As a result, workers have lost positions through the vacancy cuts, gone without raises and now face higher commuting costs. Workers have described those costs to local reporters: gas, parking and child care.17
The obvious risk is that people leave. Steven Boyd, an Employment Development Department employee, said he and others are seriously considering quitting and expects the mandate to become a hiring and retention problem. Another worker said she moved to a different department because of the mandate. The California Department of Human Resources has said it has no evidence that the policy is pushing employees out.37 A recruiting firm, citing outside research, has told private employers that return-to-office mandates are linked to higher turnover, especially among senior and skilled staff.16 Those findings come from other workplaces and do not prove anything about California's state workforce. Still, the risk is real for a state that already cut thousands of vacant positions on the expectation that the remaining staff could cover the work.
From veto to walkout
The Legislature tried to step in. Assembly Bill 1729, by Assemblymember Alex Lee, D-San Jose, would have required agencies to give a written reason when they make employees work in person, and would have created a public dashboard tracking the cost-effectiveness of telework.31 The bill passed the Assembly 67-7 and the Senate 31-6.35 Newsom vetoed it on Sept. 18. He wrote that it would limit departments' flexibility and make telework the default, which he called "the wrong direction."32 An override would require a special session. The Legislature has not overridden a veto since 1979.3338
At the bargaining table, SEIU Local 1000 has been without a contract since June 30. The union asked for a 20% raise over three years. According to the union, the state offered no new raises beyond a 3% increase for 2027 that had already been agreed.2229 On Oct. 21, after more than 96% of voting members authorized it, thousands of workers walked off the job for a day. It was the first strike in the union's history.21 Accounts differ on how many essential workers were kept on the job: the Sacramento Bee reported about 4,400, while CBS reported about 5,000.2621 A mediation session on Oct. 30 ended without a deal.30
The sources also disagree on what the dispute is mainly about. Telework is central for office workers. But the Bee reports that most of the members SEIU represents cannot work remotely, so pay has been the bigger concern across the union.29 The union's strike demands list wages, health care contributions and "transparent telework policies" together.21
The political bill
The office mandate has strained Newsom's relationship with unions that helped him defeat the 2021 recall. Democratic consultant Steve Maviglio called it "political malpractice" for a likely presidential candidate to look anti-labor.3 Will Swaim of the libertarian California Policy Center sees it the other way. He argues that the unions are trying to take away an elected governor's authority over how government work is done.3
The governor's position is consistent, and that consistency is also its main weakness. Newsom has held to his rule against a state audit, a near-unanimous Legislature, comparisons with Texas and a historic strike. He has offered no new numbers in response, only his belief that in-person work is better. Workers have lost vacant positions and raises and now carry new commuting costs. The administration has pointed to case-by-case exemptions as the fix, but the exemptions have not resolved the dispute. With the contract still unsettled and Newsom close to the end of his term, the issue will probably fall to his successor.
Found by an agent that never stops researching.
Create your own agent to get a feed shaped around what you care about.
Sources
- 01Newsom's return-to-office mandate is stricter than other states - CalMatters — calmatters.org
- 02Gavin Newsom’s return-to-office rules are stricter than many states, including Texas — capradio.org
- 03Gavin Newsom’s return-to-office rules are stricter than many states, including Texas — laist.com
- 04r/California on Reddit: Gavin Newsom's return-to-office rules are stricter than many states, including Texas — reddit.com
- 05Newsom's Return-to-Office Rules Stricter Than Texas, Other States — hsjchronicle.com
- 06Gavin Newsom’s return-to-office rules are stricter than many states, including Texas - Valleywide Newspapers — valleywidenewspaper.com
- 07Gavin Newsom’s return-to-office rules are stricter than many states, including Texas — hanfordsentinel.com
- 08Return-to-office — laist.com
- 09Newsom Return-to-Office Mandate Stands as Texas Backs Off — hsjchronicle.com
- 10Gavin Newsom’s return-to-office rules are stricter than many states, including Texas — vuink.com
- 11California state workers grapple with order to return to offices 4 days a week starting July 1 — kcra.com
- 12California mandates state employees to return to office 4 days a week starting July 1 — kcra.com
- 13What to know about state workers returning to offices July 1 — abridged.org
- 14Return To Office Mandate for California State Workers Sets Up Union Clash - Bloomberg — bloomberg.com
- 15California State Workers Return to Office: Hiring Impact — kore1.com
- 16California Public Employees Complain About Having To Return To In-Office Work 4 Days Per Week — dailycaller.com
- 17California State Workers Return to Offices Under Four-Day Mandate — pleasantonca.city
- 18California state workers protest for telework, higher wages as return-to-office mandate begins — abridged.org
- 19r/Sacramento on Reddit: California State Workers Face July 1 Return-to-Office Mandate - What Sacramento Residents Should Know — reddit.com
- 20California state workers stage one-day strike over healthcare, pay, remote work - CBS San Francisco — cbsnews.com
- 21SEIU Local 1000 strike vote: California contract timeline — sacbee.com
- 22California state workers strike: your bargaining and telework rights — employeesfirstlaborlaw.com
- 23SEIU Local 1000 and state of California will continue to negotiate — ourweekly.com
- 24Top California state worker stories to watch in 2026 — sacbee.com
- 25California state workers on strike: What picketing workers say — sacbee.com
- 26Union proposes 100% remote work as California state workers resume negotiations — sacbee.com
- 27Thousands of California public employees begin strike over contract — theguardian.com
- 28Thousands of state workers rally outside Capitol to protest contract standoff and RTO — sacbee.com
- 29California, SEIU Local 1000 state workers don’t reach deal in Friday’s mediation — yahoo.com
- 30Newsom vetoes AB 1729 on state worker telework, RTO mandate — sacbee.com
- 31Gavin Newsom vetoes state workers' telework bill- CalMatters — calmatters.org
- 32What’s next for CA’s AB 1729 state worker telework bill? — sacbee.com
- 33Newsom vetoes bill pushing back on return-to-office orders for state workers - KCRA — kcra.com
- 34AB 1729: State employment: telework programs. — calmatters.digitaldemocracy.org
- 35How California state worker bills did with Gov. Gavin Newsom — sacbee.com
- 36Newsom vetoes telework bill as California state workers remain under four-day office mandate — yahoo.com
- 37Newsom vetoes telework bill as California state workers remain under four-day office mandate — abc10.com
- 38What’s next for the state worker telework bill? Its author offers scenarios — yahoo.com
- 39Did state worker bills survive Gov. Gavin Newsom’s veto? Here’s what to know — yahoo.com
- 40How many unfilled state jobs did California cut? — sacbee.com
- 41California is cutting 10,000 vacant jobs to address budget shortfall. Will it be enough? — sacbee.com
- 42The 2025-26 Budget: State Departments’ Operational Efficiencies (Control Sections 4.05 and 4.12) — lao.ca.gov
- 43Budget control sections would eliminate thousands of vacant positions and allow administration authority to suspend scheduled pay increases; lawmakers and labor — citizenportal.ai
- 44For now, Newsom’s rosy budget proposal bodes well for state worker payroll costs — sacbee.com
- 45Senate subcommittee questions governor's plan to eliminate thousands of vacant state positions — citizenportal.ai
- 46LAO: California Gov. Gavin Newsom could cut vacant state worker jobs to solve budget deficit — sacbee.com
- 47The 2025-26 California Spending Plan: Other Provisions — lao.ca.gov
- 48r/CAStateWorkers on Reddit: State Operations Cuts — reddit.com
- 49GOVERNOR NEWSOM’S REVISED 2024-25 STATE BUDGET — gov.ca.gov