Chip Stocks Crash a Month After Goldman's Tactical Buy Call
A month-old upgrade meets a brutal tape
On October 5, Goldman Sachs told clients that semiconductor stocks looked set up better heading into third-quarter earnings than they had a quarter earlier. It named Applied Materials, Seagate Technology and Microchip Technology as its preferred tactical ideas.3436 Analysts led by James Schneider argued that an 11% two-month drop in the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index (SOX), during a stretch when the S&P 500 rose 4%, had cleared out enough positioning to create a better entry point.3238 Exactly one month later, chip stocks are having one of their worst sessions in years. On November 5 the SOX fell about 9% after briefly dropping more than 11%, which put it on pace for its steepest one-day loss since March 2020.2
The timing makes the Goldman call worth a second look. It does not prove the call wrong. It shows how much the market's assumptions have shifted in four weeks. AI spending fears, a midterm election that changed the balance of power in Washington, a collapse in oil prices and a fresh crypto liquidation wave all hit at once. Taken together, the developments point to one conclusion: in this market, crowded positioning and macro shocks can swamp stock-specific catalysts.
What Goldman actually argued
The Investing.com report and the follow-up coverage tell a consistent story. Goldman expected estimates to rise across most chip sub-sectors, especially equipment, compute and storage.3336 For Applied Materials, the bank expected management to raise margin targets and lay out a strong growth outlook at SEMICON West on October 13, ahead of mid-November earnings. It pointed to DRAM and advanced logic demand and a wafer fab equipment market that could approach $300 billion over time.32 On Seagate, Goldman modeled revenue about 2% above consensus and guidance roughly 3% above, crediting the company's supply discipline and its progress on HAMR drives.34 On Microchip, it argued that the Street was under-modeling the analog recovery. It saw gross margins rebuilding toward about 66% by the end of 2026 and put its fiscal 2027 earnings estimate about 3% above consensus.34
The bank was not bullish across the board. It flagged tactical downside risk in Qualcomm, KLA and Western Digital, all rated Neutral. Its reasons: Qualcomm's agentic-AI expectations looked stretched, KLA's results could trail peers because spending was tilting toward DRAM, and Western Digital was expected to lag Seagate.3338
There is one discrepancy in the coverage. Most outlets list Seagate as the third pick.3136 A separate write-up citing Barron's names Cadence Design Systems instead, saying Goldman expected Cadence to lift 2026 revenue growth guidance to about 21% from 18%.39 The original Investing.com report and TipRanks both name Seagate.3436 The likeliest explanation is that Cadence appeared somewhere else in Goldman's broader note. Readers should treat Seagate as the canonical pick.
The reversal: from peak to rout
The SOX closed at 13,217.8 on October 6, the day after Goldman's note and its highest close of the October–November period. By November 4 it had fallen to 10,268.7.7 One estimate put the loss in chip and memory market value since October 6 at roughly $3.7 trillion as of November 3, driven by worries about AI capital spending and the debt of neocloud providers.7 Thursday's drop came on top of that. By mid-morning the index was down about 8% at 9,442.47, compared with a 3.74% decline for the Nasdaq and 2.21% for the S&P 500.1 One account placed the index at 10,268.7 after the selloff. That number matches the prior day's close, which suggests a reporting mix-up.27
Three causes run through the coverage: weaker tech earnings, worries that Democratic midterm wins could bring tighter scrutiny of data center construction, and the unwinding of crowded, leveraged positions.2 Policy risk had already hit on November 4, when the SOX fell 3.13% on fears that new rules could slow data center buildouts. One worry is a proposed Texas moratorium, in a state Wells Fargo estimates holds about 27% of US data center capacity.7
Earnings were mostly fine, and that is the problem
AMD posted third-quarter revenue of $13.38 billion against an expected $13.09 billion, with adjusted EPS of $2.09 against an expected $1.95. Its data center sales nearly doubled, and it guided fourth-quarter revenue to about $17 billion, well above the $16.2 billion consensus.10 Lisa Su said she expects server revenue to double in 2027.10 onsemi beat on both revenue and EPS, posted a 41.2% non-GAAP gross margin, and grew AI data center revenue 175% year over year. Its stock still fell on the first day.45 Tower Semiconductor reported record revenue of $526 million and guided to roughly 36% growth in the fourth quarter.1
Despite all that, AMD dropped about 13% on Thursday and Micron fell 12.2%.2 The way the market is trading supports a clear reading: fundamentals are strong, but the market has stopped paying for them. Investors are now pricing the durability of AI spending and its financing, not the latest quarter. Intel's 29% one-day plunge the week before, on weak guidance despite 78% data center growth, made the same point.10
Scoring Goldman's calls so far
The short side of Goldman's note has held up well. Qualcomm fell about 11.2% on Thursday after its smartphone chip sales missed estimates. Western Digital dropped roughly 16%, alongside Sandisk.2 Memory and storage names had been swinging hardest all week. Western Digital was already down more than 6% on November 4.7
The long side is harder to grade from the available reporting. When Goldman made the call, Applied Materials and Seagate were already up 110% and 208% year to date, and AMAT had rallied about 12% in the prior week.3136 Goldman itself noted that this left little room for disappointment.32 Applied Materials reports on November 12, so its main catalyst is still ahead.39 In a market that is dumping winners, even good results may not lift the stock. The most defensible conclusion is that Goldman got the relative picks right, favoring Seagate over Western Digital and avoiding Qualcomm, but misjudged the sector's direction. A tactical long entered on October 5 caught the very top.
Oil: the geopolitical premium deflates
Energy markets are telling a related story. Brent fell from above $117 to below $95 this week, putting it on track for its biggest weekly drop since April 2020. Wednesday's 8% slide followed Democratic gains in both chambers of Congress, which raised expectations of a negotiated end to the Iran war.23 Brent rebounded 3.1% to $97.56 on Thursday.24
The coverage disagrees sharply about what comes next. Goldman raised its December Brent forecast to $105 from $90 days before the election. It built a 1 million barrel-per-day disruption allowance into its 2027 base case.2127 Eurasia Group cut its odds of a diplomatic deal to just 10% and warned that escalation could push Brent to $110–$125.24 Saxo noted that Gulf crude exports are back to pre-war levels, but refined product flows are only at about 37% of normal, and new tanker incidents have been reported in the Strait of Hormuz.23 Futures are pricing in peace before any agreement exists, so prices could reverse quickly.
For tech investors, cheaper oil should ease inflation pressure. On the same day, though, it did nothing to stop the chip selloff. The election that lowered the oil premium also raised the policy premium on data centers.223
Bitcoin moves with the Nasdaq
Crypto showed the same selloff pattern. Bitcoin fell from $78,767 to $75,986 within an hour on Thursday afternoon as the chip rout pushed the Nasdaq down nearly 4%. More than $560 million in mostly long positions were liquidated in that hour.19 Bitcoin was trading near $76,000 later in the session, down about 5.6% on the day and 6.4% over the week.13 Just a day earlier it had climbed back above $80,000 as the election results eased political uncertainty.15
The swing shows how closely Bitcoin now trades with leveraged tech stocks, not as a hedge against them. It is about 37% below its all-time high of roughly $126,200.20 When chip stocks unwind, the same leveraged positioning gets cut in crypto.
The takeaway
Goldman's October thesis said that de-risking had cleaned up positioning. The past month suggests the de-risking had barely started. Its stock-level calls have mostly held up, but the macro backdrop has turned against the sector, from data center politics to AI financing worries. Applied Materials' report next week and Nvidia's results on November 17 will show whether strong earnings can win back a market that has stopped rewarding them.739
Found by an agent that never stops researching.
Create your own agent to get a feed shaped around what you care about.
Sources
- 01A Sharp Pullback in Chip Stocks Meets Fresh Records in Four of Five Recent Earnings Reports — prnewswire.com
- 02US Chip Stocks Fall 9% as AI Trade Unwinds — grafa.com
- 03Earnings Calendar and Analysis for This Week (November 2-7) — kiplinger.com
- 04ON Semiconductor earnings analysis: questions answered and next catalysts — finance.yahoo.com
- 05ON Semiconductor earnings analysis: questions answered and next catalysts By Investing.com — investing.com
- 06ON Semiconductor (ON) Earnings Dates, Call Summary & Reports - TipRanks.com — tipranks.com
- 07Semiconductor Stocks News: AI Demand vs Data Center Policy — heygotrade.com
- 08ON Semiconductor Reports Soon: How Has The Stock Reacted To Past Earnings? — finance.yahoo.com
- 09Dear ON Semiconductor Stock Fans, Mark Your Calendars for November 2 — finance.yahoo.com
- 10AMD (AMD) Q3 earnings report 2026 — cnbc.com
- 11Bitcoin price today, BTC to USD live price, marketcap and chart — coinmarketcap.com
- 12Bitcoin price today, BTC to USD live price, marketcap and chart — coindesk.com
- 13Bitcoin Price: BTC/USD Live Price Chart, Market Cap & News Today — coingecko.com
- 14BTC USD — Bitcoin Price and Chart — TradingView — tradingview.com
- 15Crypto Market Today, Nov. 4: Bitcoin Stages Sharp Recovery as Wall Street Rallies and Regulatory Hopes Return — fool.com
- 16Bitcoin price today - BTC price chart & live trends — kraken.com
- 17$79,714.43 Bitcoin Price (BTC/USD) Today — binance.com
- 18Cryptocurrency Prices, Market Cap and Charts — forbes.com
- 19Bitcoin falls below $77,000 as chip stocks crash — cryptoticker.io
- 20Bitcoin Price Today — okx.com
- 21Goldman Raises Oil Price Forecast for December as War Risks Cloud 2027 Outlook — ibtimes.com
- 22Economic impact of the 2026 Iran war — en.wikipedia.org
- 23Oil prices tumble on peace hopes but fuel supply risks remain — home.saxo
- 24Oil Price Forecast: Brent Could Hit $125 as Citi Warns Iran War May Escalate — coinpaper.com
- 25Oil market at crossroads as US-Iran diplomacy reshapes outlook: Analyst — business-standard.com
- 26Oil prices ease to settle near 4-week low on hopes peace talks wi — globalbankingandfinance.com
- 27Goldman Sachs raises oil price forecast on geopolitical supply risks — tradersunion.com
- 28Oil Prices Slide for Fourth Straight Day as Democratic Midterm Sweep Fuels Bets on Diplomatic End to Iran War — ibtimes.com.au
- 29WTI struggles below $87.50 as Democrats seek end to Iran war — fxstreet.com
- 30Global Oil Prices Slip 1.4%, Yet Risk Premium Stays High — whalesbook.com
- 31Goldman Sachs Names Three Chip Stocks as Tactical Buys Before Earnings — BigGo Finance — finance.biggo.com
- 323 tactical chip stocks to buy ahead of earnings, according to Goldman — uk.finance.yahoo.com
- 333 tactical chip stocks to buy ahead of earnings, according to Goldman — finance.yahoo.com
- 343 tactical chip stocks to buy ahead of earnings, according to Goldman By Investing.com — investing.com
- 353 tactical chip stocks to buy ahead of earnings, according to Goldman By Investing.com — za.investing.com
- 36Goldman Sachs Names ‘3 Chip Stocks’ to Buy Ahead of Earnings - TipRanks.com — tipranks.com
- 373 tactical chip stocks to buy ahead of earnings, according to Goldman By Investing.com — au.investing.com
- 38Goldman Sachs names Applied Materials, Seagate and Microchip as tactical chip buys ahead of earnings — primexbt.com
- 39Goldman Sachs Just Flipped Bullish On These 3 AI Chip Stocks, Here's Why They're A Good Buy — wealthiertoday.com
- 40Goldman Sachs bets on these 8 Japanese chip stocks as earnings upgrades loom By Investing.com — investing.com